Pine Island Real Estate

Although Pine Island is only 30 minutes from Ft. Myers, Florida, its secluded, waterfront charm makes it one of the West Coast’s hidden gems. The friendly residents and rural setting provide a “small town” atmosphere reminiscent of old-style Florida. The Island is home to four communities – Bokeelia, St. James City, Matlacha, and Pineland – all with their own fire department, marinas, shops, and distinctive appeal.

Fringed with mangroves and three aquatic preserves, Pine Island boasts a variety of wildlife including bald eagles, manatees, osprey and heron. Flowering plants and lush greenery add to the tropical feel.

With easy access to the Gulf of Mexico, Pine Island is well known to fishing and boating enthusiasts. Affordable waterfront homes with deep boat dockage enable anyone to take advantage of the Island lifestyle. Despite the waterfront setting, Pine Island has largely escaped the concrete and skyscrapers dominant in other more touristy areas of the Coast. Zoning restrictions protect the Island from high-rise developments, assuring the Island’s allure for generations to come.

Pine Island Homes For Sale

Pine Island Homes For Sale November 30, 2021
55
Listed
64
Avg. DOM
$392.84
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
$500,500
Med. List Price
55 Properties
Page 1 of 5
$6,500,000
Subdivision: Acreage
5
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
4,968
Sq.Ft.
2018
Year Built
9
Days on Site
221081832
MLS
800 ft on the canal + 300 feet on the bay! 2-year old mansion of SHEER LUXURY where privacy is cherished on 1.62 acres! Furnished turn-key! Private gated entry to an 800 ft paved driveway lined with...
$1,468,000
Subdivision: Matlacha Isles
5
Beds
3F21/2
Baths
3,073
Sq.Ft.
2019
Year Built
77
Days on Site
221066100
MLS
Amazing location in Majestic Matlacha! Luxury Island Living! This stunning Matlacha home built in 2019 sits on 0.31 acres with 130 ft of frontage and offers just as much outdoor living space as in!...
5
Beds
4F21/2
Baths
3,165
Sq.Ft.
1947
Year Built
109
Days on Site
221059216
MLS
Investor's dream spot in Matlacha! Within walking distance to all of Matlacha's best seafood, art galleries, and shops, lies one of Southwest Florida's most historic properties. Originally...
$1,100,000
Subdivision: Pine Island
4
Beds
4
Baths
2,277
Sq.Ft.
1938
Year Built
47
Days on Site
221073514
MLS
Located in beautiful and quirky Matlacha, your adventure begins! Welcome to this updated DUPLEX that features 2 bedrooms + 2 bathrooms on each side. Step out back and take in the endless waterfront...
$1,095,000
Subdivision: Island Harbors
5
Beds
4
Baths
3,272
Sq.Ft.
1990
Year Built
79
Days on Site
221065568
MLS
Excellent opportunity to own this meticulously maintained furnished 5 Br, 4 full bath gulf access waterfront home. Unique floor plan has the living room located at the end of the canal with lots of...
3
Beds
2F11/2
Baths
1,728
Sq.Ft.
1977
Year Built
105
Days on Site
221060158
MLS
MILLION DOLLAR VIEW! Enjoy waking up to the beautiful back bay with the tropical wildlife that Pine Island offers. This lovely home has an open floor plan with amazing kitchen, stainless upgraded...
$1,000,000
Subdivision: Pine Island Fill
4
Beds
3
Baths
1,284
Sq.Ft.
1950
Year Built
63
Days on Site
221069679
MLS
Adorable, renovated Matlacha waterfront property includes TWO historical cottages with SUNSET VIEWS NIGHTLY! This property is two homes in one, both wonderfully renovated by a prominent local luxury...
$969,900
Subdivision: Sandy Shoals
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,672
Sq.Ft.
2016
Year Built
45
Days on Site
221066690
MLS
LIGHTENING FAST GULF ACCESS & NO BRIDGES! Situated in a highly desired area of Southwest Florida on a large lot, this single-family pool home offers everything you need to enjoy the waterfront...
$949,900
Subdivision: Matlacha
3
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
1,926
Sq.Ft.
2007
Year Built
1
Day on Site
221082996
MLS
This home features some of the best water views in the area and it comes Furnished. It is stilted with kitchen, dining, living room, and 1 bedroom/office on the 2nd floor and a huge master bedroom...
$924,900
Subdivision: BUTTONWOOD KEY
3
Beds
2F11/2
Baths
2,351
Sq.Ft.
2009
Year Built
23
Days on Site
221077993
MLS
"BUTTONWOOD KEY" ST. JAMES CITY SPECTACULAR CUSTOM BUILT, DEEP WATER DIRECT ACCESS WATERFRONT (NEWER BUILT 2009) FLORIDA COASTAL HOME W/OVER $250,000 (+/-) IN UPGRADES & RENOVATIONS. THIS 3BDR, DEN,...
$899,000
Subdivision: Calusa Ridge
3
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
2,501
Sq.Ft.
2014
Year Built
2
Days on Site
221082784
MLS
Luxury estate home in Calusa Ridge, the premier gated community on Bokeelia. Built in 2014 it has ONLY been used for about 1 year in total & shows as a brand new home! Lake front with approximately 1...
$890,000
Subdivision: Buttonwood Key
3
Beds
2F11/2
Baths
1,634
Sq.Ft.
1995
Year Built
84
Days on Site
221064931
MLS
Private and Quiet Buttonwood Key. Perhaps the premier location on Buttonwood Key sits on a beautiful double lot, well set back from the street with lots of distance between both neighboring homes....